Categories: Stories

Why Mnangagwa wants Mugabe to appoint the Chief Justice

Thus, the restrictions have been placed in amending these two provisions in our Constitution not on the basis of time but procedure.  This is what we refer to as entrenchments. These entrenchments also apply to provisions relating to the amendment of term limits provisions and Section 328 itself; as prescribed by Section 328 (7) and (9) respectively. Section 328 (9) restricts the amendment of Section 328 itself, in case someone wants to amend the amendment clause first before attempting to amend other provisions.

The provisions from which this particular amendment proposal on appointment of judges arise, are not entrenched and thus are subject to amendments as long as the proper procedures are followed, and of course, when the rationale of the need of that amendment is found, either by the Government of the day or by any Member of Parliament, who would wish to sponsor a Private Bill. In this case, we are following the procedure prescribed in terms of Section 328 to the letter and spirit, and thus, no issues of constitutional ripeness or otherwise legally arise, particularly on the benchmark of time.

Mr. Speaker, now that we learn that there is no provision in our Constitution that prescribes the time within which a constitutional amendment may be brought before this august House, one may want to learn from even our neighbour, South Africa which adopted their Constitution in 1996 and started to be operational in 1997. The South African Constitution came into effect on 4th February, 1997 and by 28th August, 1997 barely seven months after the effective date, the late President Mandela was signing a constitutional amendment into law, with less than six months of it coming into effect. It made changes related to the Oath of Office of the Acting President and to the jurisdiction of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission, and also to the effect that the Chief Justice should designate another judge to administer the Oath of Office of the President or Acting President, rather than administering it personally.

As a comparative analysis, how do you reconcile the more than four years that our Constitution has been in effect and the less than seven months within which South Africans changed their Constitution? That notwithstanding, the South African people remain proud of their Constitution even when it was changed within six months. I believe that other than some of our own such as Hon. Ndebele, whose pride as a Zimbabwean has been dented simply because we have proposed a constitutional amendment within four years.

Mr. Speaker, it arises from the above South African example that it is not true that a Constitution cannot be amended within four years as in our case, as long as that amendment is legally and procedurally executed as we hereby do. It is trite that while intended to be both foundational and enduring; constitutions are not intended to be immutable. In fact, if the Constitution is to endure, it must be able to respond to changing needs and circumstances. Some amendments are made for the public interests; or to adjust the Constitution to the environment within which the political system operates, including economics, technology, international relations, demographic and values. They can be changed to correct provisions that have proved inadequate over time, or to further improve constitutional rights or to strengthen democratic institutions.

Continued next page

(512 VIEWS)

Don't be shellfish... Please SHARE
Google
Twitter
Facebook
Linkedin
Email
Print

This post was last modified on June 14, 2017 1:43 pm

Page: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

Charles Rukuni

The Insider is a political and business bulletin about Zimbabwe, edited by Charles Rukuni. Founded in 1990, it was a printed 12-page subscription only newsletter until 2003 when Zimbabwe's hyper-inflation made it impossible to continue printing.

Recent Posts

Mnangagwa spokesman says there is nothing to celebrate about latest US move on Zimbabwe sanctions

President Emmerson Mnangagwa’s spokesman George Charamba says there is nothing to celebrate about the United…

April 17, 2024

Two British aristocrats target one of Zimbabwe’s biggest lithium assets

Over drinks back in 2019, two British tycoons, Algy Cluff and Michael Spencer, agreed to…

April 16, 2024

Chamisa accused of destroying the opposition but says opposition is not one person

Former Citizens Coalition for Change leader Nelson Chamisa has been accused of destroying the opposition…

April 15, 2024

Zimbabwe central bank governor says people will soon be scrambling for ZiG, fears deflation

Zimbabwe central bank governor John Mushayavanhu says people will soon be scrambling for the country’s…

April 12, 2024

List of Zimbabweans and entities on the Canadian sanctions list

Exiled former Higher Education Minister Jonathan Moyo has raised an interesting question. Why is Canada…

April 12, 2024

23 questions and answers on Zimbabwe’s new currency

The Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe has published 23 questions and answers about its newly introduced…

April 12, 2024