Since 1960, Africa has received billions of dollars in aid. In the last 30 years alone, one estimate puts aid to the continent at US$1.2 trillion, though distributed very unevenly across the continent. In this time, African economies have developed.
Life expectancy and populations have both risen dramatically, and absolute poverty has fallen. Yet the rise in living standards has been relatively meagre, and few African countries have achieved the rapid economic growth seen in much of Asia – in South Korea, China, Vietnam, Indonesia, India or Bangladesh – in the same period.
Why has so much aid failed to deliver the economic transformation seen elsewhere? Is it too much, or never enough? Has it helped or hindered? Can it be useful and productive, or should it be stopped?
These are the core questions addressed in Greg Mills’ latest book, Expensive Poverty: Why aid fails and how it can work.
Mills is director of the Brenthurst Foundation, a South African think-tank funded partly by the Oppenheimer family. His approach to these questions is driven less by ideology than by decades of hands-on experience in countries as diverse as Zambia, Somalia, Ghana, Pakistan, and Afghanistan, where the organisation is working with business and civil society as well as governments. His book draws deeply on this experience as well as on a wide literature and an even wider range of practical examples.
Mills identifies three core reasons aid has failed to deliver the transformation expected:
He addresses, in particular, the constant appeals for a “Marshall Plan for Africa”, and the seductive appeal of the Chinese model of “authoritarian development”.
The original Marshall Plan, a 1948 American plan to provide foreign aid to Western Europe after WW2, worked for several reasons:
Continued next page
(85 VIEWS)
This post was last modified on August 20, 2022 11:25 am
Africans must now tell their own stories because if they continue to denigrate themselves they…
Quarterly taxes, which are due next month, will force businesses to sell a quota of…
Zimbabweans will soon be able to change their ZiG to United States dollars and vice-versa…
Senator Sengezo Tshabangu yesterday expressed dismay at the pace at which the government is constructing…
Zimbabwe has ordered providers of goods and services to use the official exchange rate or…
Zimbabwe is going to introduce legislation which ensures that the country uses one exchange rate…