Categories: Stories

What Zimbabwe MPs said about the Constitution Amendment Bill-Part Three

In terms of this Constitution, Section 164 (2) (b) enjoins and requires Members of this august House to, I will read it; “The State must, through legislative and other measures, assist and protect the courts to ensure their independence and in partiality, dignity, accessibility and effectiveness.”  Mr. Chairman Sir, demoting a judge is a direct attack on the whole pillar of judicial independence.  If you demote, it is not allowed in this Constitution.  This House must not be complicit to undermine the authority of the judiciary by demoting a Judge President of the Labour Court to be merely called a senior judge.

If this august House fulfills its duty as is said here, each and every Member of Parliament must assist and protect the courts to ensure their independence.  Demoting the Judge President of the Labour Court to a mere senior judge is indeed, the opposite of assisting and protecting judges in holding their independence. For that reason, I object Mr. Chairman.

HON. ADV. CHAMISA: Thank you Hon. Chair.  My debate is to implore on the Hon. Vice President to restore what is currently obtaining, that is the Judge President as opposed to a senior judge.  I have got two to three reasons why I am advancing this view and notion.  The first one is that, if you look at the change of name, it has a teleological and purposive effect to indicate that you are changing the purpose, the role and the stature.  This is not just a jurisprudential perception or perspective.

It also obtains even in the Bible; you know that when the role is changing from one to the other, for example the case of Jacob, he had to change to being called Israel.  Abram had to be called Abraham, it depicted and denoted a change in the function and purpose.  Now, when the Vice President and the Government choose to change the nomenclature, classification and taxonomy, legally of a judge in the labour court, what are we sending as an impression; which is what we experience everyday Hon. Chair as lawyers in the labour court?  The labour court is then viewed as a lesser court, a ‘zhing-zhong’ court and a court that is dispensing lesser justice.  It does not advance the objective we have seen being induced and infected into the Constitution.

The spirit within the Constitution was to elevate the dispensing of justice at the work place to the level that is obtaining at the High Court.  It is so important to realise that the labour court is a court sui generis; it is in a class of its own.  It must be given sufficient teeth, stature and clout for it to dispense labour justice and workplace justice and equity.  Once you start doing this, you are now casualising labour justice at the workplace.  You are bastardising labour justice and it has an effect of subtracting from that stature.

Hon. Chair, this is why I would kindly make my supplication to the Vice President to retain the Judge President and not just end there because the naming is the beginning.  We must also even in terms of our norming, begin to give the labour court sufficient attention, the attention that is given to all the other equivalent judges and offices within the High Court.  On this one, Hon. Chair, I do not think that it is advancing a positive and progressive image, particularly to the trade unionist and the workers in general.

Continued next page

(156 VIEWS)

Don't be shellfish... Please SHARE
Google
Twitter
Facebook
Linkedin
Email
Print

This post was last modified on June 22, 2017 9:13 pm

Page: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7

Charles Rukuni

The Insider is a political and business bulletin about Zimbabwe, edited by Charles Rukuni. Founded in 1990, it was a printed 12-page subscription only newsletter until 2003 when Zimbabwe's hyper-inflation made it impossible to continue printing.

Recent Posts

Zimbabwe worried ZiG is appreciating too fast?

Zimbabwe, whose currency declined 80% this year before being abandoned, is now worried about its…

April 19, 2024

ZiG confusion

Zimbabwe’s new currency, the Zimbabwe Gold (ZiG,) continued to firm against the United States dollar…

April 19, 2024

US congratulates Zimbabwe on its 44th anniversary, but maintains sanctions on the country

United States Secretary of State Antony Blinken has congratulated Zimbabwe on its 44th independence anniversary…

April 18, 2024

Did you know that if America’s billionaires were considered a country they would be the third richest nation in the world?

The 813 billionaires in the United States have a total wealth of US$5.7 trillion. If…

April 17, 2024

Mnangagwa spokesman says there is nothing to celebrate about latest US move on Zimbabwe sanctions

President Emmerson Mnangagwa’s spokesman George Charamba says there is nothing to celebrate about the United…

April 17, 2024

Two British aristocrats target one of Zimbabwe’s biggest lithium assets

Over drinks back in 2019, two British tycoons, Algy Cluff and Michael Spencer, agreed to…

April 16, 2024